Sorry for the "gas shock" with your new boat... Fact is, boats (other than sail) were never made to be fuel efficient...
The guys telling you that your 50hp is too small - well, that's just their opinion... (we all have 'em, of course) but, your "gas usage" has nothing to do with your motor being too small. In fact, if you want to burn more gas - simply get a bigger engine.
Your vessel has a designed hull speed... once you are at that speed - that should be it - period! Exceeding this speed has a very dramatic effect on the energy it takes move your vessel forward and to make it go any faster...
On the other hand, the one thing that will affect your gas usage (other than your engine being tuned and in good condition) is your "prop"... The size and type of your prop may not be what you want on that boat... and believe me, it is amazing the difference in performance and fuel they can make (even dents, cracks, bends, can make a difference.
Pontoons were not designed for speed. In fact, the very first use of these vessels were in WWI for being towed... The military used them by towing them up rivers with supplies, and also to make bridges by tying them side to side across rivers and then laying tracks across them for men and machines to move across. Most of them were later sold as military surplus and of course, didn't become popular until the 60's after some fisherman decided to put a small motor on the back of it and a lawn chair on the deck of it.
So, have your prop checked out... I mean you can check it for dents and to see if it is cracked or bent - but you really need to take it by a knowledgeable mechanic and see if you have the right prop on it... you need a balanced prop that will give you the correct amount of "thrust" not speed at low rpms...
Now, having said all that... 6 gallons in two hours is not bad at all for a 50hp engine... about the only way you are going to improve on that in a dramatic way is to go electric -
Happy & Safe Boating!
http://boatwrights.org