Question:
carolina skiff jv 17 or boston whaler montauk 15?
anonymous
1970-01-01 00:00:00 UTC
carolina skiff jv 17 or boston whaler montauk 15?
Six answers:
?
2016-05-22 14:05:08 UTC
I have the 15' "Sport", Great Boat ! it can go places no other 15' would DARE go, Are you refering to the 17' Montauk model ? In either case it's the best boat in that size class, HANDS DOWN ! double hulled constructruction filled with closed cell floatation makes them UNSINKABLE, even after 2000 rounds from a machine gun, it still floats, they drive trucks over them and the hull's don't break (you don't see the competition doing that). They are expensive but, simple, I paid $3100 for my 15' sport in 1990 without a trailer, I still have the boat ! 2- summers ago there was a jet ski accident in the bay, a kid jumped a wake, and hit a bouey, it knocked him out, and injured him badly, the current drifted him up into the tidal flats at high tide, other boats could NOT get to the unconscience kid and were calling the coast guard, I just hit the "Tilt" UP on the engine, and with my "Shallow Draft" nosed up to the kid, grabbed his head out of the water "GOTCHA" !, the coast guard showed up (in less than 10 minutes), we put a backboard on him (broken hip), but could not get him on board with 3 people lifting, the poor kid was in agony, the coast guard to my surprise said, "is it O.K if we slide him onto the "Whaler" since it's lower to the water", I said "Let's Go", we did, the backboard slid right on the nose, the CG got on board, and their boat gave me an escort to a waiting ambulance, the kid lived, and another whaler "LEGEND" is born. People say to me "how can you afford to put your family in a "Boston Whaler" ?..... My reply.... "How can I afford NOT to" ! His mother called and thanked me, she also called "Whaler" and THANKED THEM !
MICHAEL S
2008-05-30 13:01:28 UTC
Boston Whaler, we own a 27 foot outrage and previously had a 18 foot outrage. They are tough boats, hold their value better than most boats, and the peace of mind that goes with a totally unsinkable boat!
Richard C
2008-05-30 05:29:23 UTC
I think you'd like the Whaler better in the long run. I like the skiff but I note "engine work' that could mean $$$$ now. Don't forget to "THANK DAD" !!!!!!
kenbgray
2008-05-30 04:26:24 UTC
Go with the whaler better boat alround.
anonymous
2008-05-30 01:31:34 UTC
boston whaler. if your fishing the bimini will only get in the way. 2 ft isnt to much of a loss. plus the boston got more acc.
Captain Bill
2008-05-30 05:05:19 UTC
The whaler looks like it would be YOUR best choice.



The Carolina Skiff maybe a more stable fishing platform, but if the engine is questionable that would not be good to have it break down and not be able to motor home.



Just be safe and - Have Fun!


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...